The blogpackinglight gear awards

As TGO magazine is in the process of doing their awards, I thought I’d pre-empt them by doing my own awards. These are totally subjective and based solely on my experience over the past few years.

Gold Award: Tarptent Scarp 1

The Scarp 1 is the best tent I’ve owned. It may not be the lightest or most elegant, but every time I’ve used another shelter, I’ve wanted to go back to the Scarp. First and foremost, it’s a very strong tent and can withstand pretty much anything the weather can throw at it. The secret of its stability is the PitchLoc corner struts which secure the ends of the tent and are incredibly strong and stable. For a one man tent it has enough floor space to sleep comfortably, with good headroom, and to store gear. The two porches are big enough for cooking and give tremendous flexibility for gear storage, especially in wet weather. The roof vents are effective in reducing condensation. It’s not perfect. Some decent pockets in the inner tent and a better inner door configuration (inverted T, please) would improve it. However, overall, I think it’s the best bit of gear I own and well worth the gold award.

Silver award: Gossamer Gear Mariposa 2012

The original Mariposa Plus was a very good rucksack, possibly the most comfortable I’ve used (along with the Lightwave Ultrahike). The 2012 version has improved on the Plus significantly. The aluminium stay, wider hip-belt and redesigned shoulder straps have made the 2012 Mariposa even more comfortable to carry. The change of material to dyneema gridstop has made the pack a lot more robust. The mesh side pockets have been replaced with gridstop alleviating concerns over abrasion. The front pocket is now stretchy mesh, making it easier to pack. Decent sized hip belt pockets mean I no longer have to use a belt pack for camera and snacks. The over the top closure is unusual but works well. On the two trips that I’ve found the 2012 Mariposa to be a really excellent pack.

Bronze award: Snow Peak GST100 canister stove

This little stove has been a constant companion over the past five year apart from a brief dalliance with a JetBoil. The only thing that has ever gone wrong was the piezo button popped out. It was soon fixed and I’ve had no problems since. The piezo igniter has never failed. The stove simmers well and seems to be quite frugal on fuel. The construction is very sturdy with four solid titanium pan supports. It folds down small and weighs 87g. It’s a superb piece of quality engineering. I love it and can’t see that I’ll change it.

Honourable mentions:

Rab Drillium overtrousers – these are the only overtrousers I’ve ever felt totally comfortable in. They are very breathable and the material is soft, so it doesn’t feel like you are wearing a crisp packet.

MLD eVent gaiters – simple, no nonsense gaiters that keep the crud out of your boots and muck off your legs. At 101g, they weigh next to nothing. They don’t fall down and they aren’t sweaty. Great for boggy ground. walking pole extender – this are a genius bit of lateral thinking that joins two walking poles so they can be used as a pole for a pyramid shelter. Simple, light and effective.

That’s my awards, now we wait to see what the great and the good select for the TGO Magazine awards.


22 thoughts on “The blogpackinglight gear awards”

  1. Good idea Robin. Some excellent choices there. I have the original Mariposa and the newer version does appear better. I also have the event gaiters from MLD and you dont know you are wearing them.
    I might have to indulge in a little plagiarism of my own and do a similar list 🙂 but will wait until I have had chance to test out a few new bits of kit

  2. Good call on the stove. I have the Snow Peak Ti Gigapower which seems almost identical except I don’t have a piezo igniter. Depite sometimes playing with meths I pretty much always return to it. BTW the pole joiner, shouldn’t that be

  3. I couldn’t agree more with your Gold Award. The Scarp 1 is a fabulous tent. I haven’t used any of your other choices but they all look good and the Mariposa is definitely in the mix for my upgraded/larger bag candidate for longer trips next year.

  4. I liked the old Gorilla despite its flaws and not the new one. Had a look at the new Mariposa and I do think it is a good pack.

    Scarp is the best tent going. Simple as that. I miss mine a lot. Why oh why I sold it is now lost on me. Nick has it put to good use and that is some comfort.

  5. What about yout Duomid , Robin. Not even an honourable mention, I see !
    Be interested to know what tweaks you are having done with Ooworks.

    1. I thought hard about it but decided I could only pick one shelter.

      Mods are a couple of extra pegging points at rear and a linelok on door.

    1. It’s just a tent footprint from Hilliberg. I cut it in half so it covers the vestibule space. It’s no problem to use with a gas stove. I use canister feet for stability.

  6. Excellent list, and I’ve never heard of the Lightwave Ultrahike, so I must check that out. I have an original GG Mariposa Plus updated with the wire aluminum frame – it’s well used and I like it. Also have the same Gigapower stove, but I’ve had two of the piezo ignitors fail: one due to sea water (boating accident in Indonesia) and another time because my salt shaker spilled wet salty water on it. Your tent award is good – I have a Tarptent Rainbow that I like. I’d nominate the GG two piece trekking poles as well, if you use poles as I do. Excellent list and well written, thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.